SOA / Web Services / Java

A Technology Blog

When to use REST based web services?

Posted by Vivek on March 11, 2009

REST expose a much simpler interface than SOAP, with some limitations. Development with REST is easier and quicker and this is the reason why most famous web APIs are REST-based.
 
The limitations are related to the protocol: with REST you are bound to HTTP. So it is difficult to handle different transports like MQ or JMS. So if you are designing an application to be used exclusively on the web, REST could be the option. If you are designing a SOA for an Enterprise, that needs to interconnect to multiple systems using multiple transport/channels and having sophisticated transactions to be modeled with BPMs, then it is better to go with SOAP.
Note than you are going to pay SOAP’s flexibility with development complexity: SOAP interfaces are described by the WSDL standard which looks really complicated and is not supposed to be read by humans.

RESTful applications simply rely on the built-in HTTP security (the HTTPS protocol), with SOAP you can have more sophisticated choices, like WS-Security that lets you encrypt only portions of the messages and moves the security handling from the transport layer to the message layer.

REST is younger than SOAP, so it is not as well supported by commercial products (both BPM and ESB products). However new versions of the major ESBs support REST (ex mule, openesb).

RESTful services do not have a strict describtor, they tried to define something simmilar to WSDL, it’s called WADL (https://wadl.dev.java.net/). The WADL is currently not a common standard the adoption is very low and mostly not wanted for RESTful services.

Even for ESB’s most of the vendors where lacking the support some month ago. But now nearly each big ESB vendor (commercial or open source) supports the RESTful protocol. From the usage of an ESB it is currently not a problem to run RESTful services.

If you plan to run a very big deployment with many data interfaces, you will get great benefits using RESTful Services. REST is based 100% on the HTTP rfc (http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616.html). Many of the RESTful Interface which you see currently on the internet do not fully support HTTP specification, the result is that they could not benefit from it in terms of performance, caching, content negotiation and security. 
One great reason is to use RESTful interfaces is it can easily support different content-types/mime-types. First you think about, vendor specific XML with a xsd definition, later you would like to support AJAX Mashups and even later you think about to support text formats, reports in PDF, and so on. This is very easy to implement with REST because you query always with the same data query but the requested content type is just different.
Another reason why people are using RESTful interfaces is to be scalable like the web (www) and google. This is possible when you are using plain and simple HTTP protocol. You have support from so many standard product like web proxy caches (like SQUID) or other to scale your application a very low effort. For Social Communities you have have now a new Standard for RESTful Service Security. It is called Oauth (http://oauth.net/) which makes authentication over HTTP very easy.

Some other examples where RESTFul Services are dominant:
Amazon AWS: E.g. they offer Services for Storage (S3) and they have SOAP and REST interfaces but over 90% of the clients are using REST
Google Maps is using RESTful uris to provide cachable map tiles
yahoo API’s are mostly build with RESTful interfaces
RESTful Services are very dominant in lighweight web 2.0 API’s for Mashups like OpenSocial
API.

REST design is good for the database driven applications and when client wants quick integration.

Advertisements

12 Responses to “When to use REST based web services?”

  1. […] When to use REST based web services? « SOA / Web Services / Java […]

    Like

  2. Keyur Patel(MCP) said

    Really good articles to understand about REST based service.

    Like

  3. Great blog. Really amazing and knowledgeable.

    Like

  4. AK said

    Thanks a lot buddy.. very informative..

    Like

  5. Suyog Doshi said

    Thanks buddy really good artical

    Like

  6. Zulfiqar said

    it helps me
    thnx dude

    Like

  7. Was looking for something which can give me fair comparison between SOAP and REST based web services. Very lucid explanation along with fair references.

    Keep it up !

    Thanks,
    Pawankumar Jajara

    Like

  8. sriram said

    Hi,

    presently I am working on REST web services.

    1) Can you please provide me one simple example to handle security level. It means, how to send request through browser sensitive data(ex: credit card information) with encryption?

    Like

  9. everything about java…

    […]When to use REST based web services? « SOA / Web Services / Java[…]…

    Like

  10. Pavan said

    Great article about the RESTFul webservices. In the other blogs i read an article REST will support cross platform languages. is that right ?

    Like

  11. usha said

    thanks .it is realy informative

    Like

  12. How would you go about implementing the RESTful Web service using the framework of your choice?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: